I used to go to NYCB's Nutcracker on New Year's Eve, where the dancers would get or act a bit tipsy and change around the choreography: one of the dolls would not appear, leaving the other doll to improvise a solo; the shepherdesses would make a jete exit, leaving the soloist along on stage, etc.
That was nothing compared to the performance I saw this afternoon with a family who had never seen The Nutcracker before. The changes that were made were so widespread, including interpolated Christmas carols and some non-Tchaikovskian chords and rhythms by the orchestra into the score, that it took organizational skills of the highest level to pull off. I'm sure I missed a great number of things, but these are the ones I remember: Olivier Wevers as Drosselmeyer made the first appearance, emerging through a "basement" door, and he tripped onto the stage! (I hope this was planned and not a prank.) There was a party guest who was a bit randier and more forward than usual -- there was a lot more hitting on Frau Stahlbaum in general, perhaps inspired by the lovely Stacy Lowenberg -- and some slapstick collisions were added, causing a domino effect at one point during the party dances. Drosselmeyer made the two dolls move by using a remote. Brittany Reid, Lucien Postlewaite, and Anton Pankevitch wore shiny red noses behind their masks in Masque. In the fight scene, the head Warrior Mouse wielded a light saber instead of a sword. One of the little mice looked like s/he was dressed as a super-hero, but that could have been the lighting. Some of the older warrior mice were playful, tripping each other up. The snowflakes staged a good, old-fashioned snowball fight, stocking up after each exit, without missing a step. The stagehands were in on it, too, causing a mini-storm mid-way through, and a blizzard at the end. The singers in the snow scene chanted, "Scoo--bie, scoobie do" during the wordless chorus.
In the second act, the Costume Shop was raided. Pasha (Drosselmeyer's dream character) usually wears orange harem pants; Wevers wore bright red shorts with black trim that would have been at home in a Nicolo Fonte piece. With his wide belt, he looked like he was out of the World Wrestling Federation, and at one point, while the Prince and Drosselmeyer are circling each other trying to get the upper hand, Wevers and Herd, the Prince, did a stomach bump. There were elf hats everywhere, and Karel Cruz in the Moors was wearing a Santa beard with his hat. In Peacock, Wevers pulled a peacock feather from Kylee Kitchens' mane, and it appeared throughout the act. The dervishes wore white wigs instead of black ones. The man in Commedia wore red breeches, like the Prince, and the women wore hats and garland necklaces. At one point in the section, one of the Colombines (Lowenberg and Kari Brunson) held up a little piece of mistletoe, and Lucien Postlewaite ignored her and kissed the other girl. Drosselmeyer gave the peacock feather to Clara, who passed it to Korbes' Flora. Korbes passed it to one of the Flowers, who passed it to another, and another, and to one who offered it and then pulled it away, with Korbes getting it back at the end. Again, none of the Flowers missed a beat or a step. The flowers rummaged the costume shop headdress section, each choosing a different one, and one flower wore a red flower in hers.
For the most part, there was no visible interference with the carefully choreographed parts for children. However, the peacock feather did make it back to Clara at the end, who woke up from her dream with it. Marina Taylor, who played the young Clara, brought it onstage for the curtain call, where it was passed, finally, to conductor Allan Dameron. That wasn't the end of the snow, however; Wevers and Pasha's two attendents carried out boxes full, which they dumped on the orchestra during their bows.
For adults, and some children, who had seen the ballet before, it was like a puzzle trying to figure out what was different. There were plenty of laughs, and I didn't always get what caused it, which means I'm sure I missed out on some very clever stage action and references. Even though the people I was with had never seen the ballet before, they started to guess what was probably different. (And they were right a remarkable percentage of the time.)
The adult leads played it almost entirely straight: most of the party guests, the parents, the dolls, Clara, Prince, Peacock, Dervishes, Flora, and the choreography was danced intact. And the dancing was superb: Kitchens was pristine as the Ballerina doll and a mysterious, unfolding creature as Peacock. Kiyon Gaines danced the Soldier Doll was such softness and so classically, he could have been dancing Donizetti Variations or Emeralds. Red noses aside, Pankevitch's and Postlewaite's turnout and placement in the Masque was a joy to watch, and Brittany Reid was expansive as Pirlipat. Cruz was an elegant Warrior Mouse, which doesn't seem possible, and he and Lindsi Dec were charming as the Moors. Korbes was a lilting dream as Flora amidst the swirling of the flowers. Mara Vinson was a radiant Clara, and Casey Herd a gallant Prince. They both keep dancing better and better with each new challenge.
Amidst the high cheer of the season and this special performance, was really stood out was how beautiful the choreography is, end to end.
