I guess I'll start this off. I went to tonight's performance, starring the newly promoted Sterling Hyltin, Robert Fairchild, Daniel Ulbricht as Mercutio, and Darci Kistler and Jock Soto as the Capulets.
I'd never seen this production before, so I went in with an open mind.
This R+J is hard to like. There's the ugliness of the decor -- the grim Great Wall of China-like single set device that never gave the ballet any sense of time, place, or decor. This was most apparent during the "bed" scene -- Romeo and Juliet were forced to frolic on a tiny block that served as a "bed." Most of the dancers were forced to basically dance on a blank stage, and some of them seemed confused about the blocking. Also, there are weird stage directions and cuts. For instance, during the Capulet party, there's no scene of Romeo, Mercutio, and Benvolio standing by the doorway of the Capulets and sneaking in. They just sort of saunter onstage mid-party. The charming scene with Juliet playing her mandolin is gone. Romeo and Juliet also never have that scene in the party when they are alone for the first time and fall in love. They seem to flirt in open view of their parents and Tybalt. Also, whoever thought of ending Act 1 with the anti-climactic scene of the Nurse sending a note to Romeo? The ballet works much better ending after the Balcony Scene.
The choreography is better for the men than the women. The crowd scenes in particular become displays for the men of NYCB to show their stuff in a seemingly endless series of pirouettes and entrechats. The key balcony scene has some very awkward lifts, including one where Romeo holds Juliet almost completely parallel to the ground. The climactic kiss was awkward too -- Juliet is sitting on the ground, bending over backwards, and I thought "ouch" rather than "ahh."
The weakest scene is maybe the bedroom scene. Juliet wakes up, looking somewhat bored. Romeo wakes up, and he starts to chase her around and all of a sudden she's the coquettish girl, who resists his advances until they roll into bed and are waken up by the nurse. This makes no dramatic sense whatsoever -- they supposedly just had their wedding night, and now it's time for a painful departure. Where's the passion? The sadness? The desperation? Watch Fonteyn and Nureyev dance this scene to see how it's done.
The "slap" scene is IMO actually the strongest. Up until now Martins' Juliet had been irritatingly childlike, but the "slap" seems to awaken Juliet into maturity. That being said, Darci Kistler plays Lady Capulet like a sympathetic mother, which isn't true to Shakespeare at all.
But ... despite the best efforts of Martins and whoever designed the production, they couldn't kill Romeo and Juliet. For one, the music remains one of ballet's best, most evocative scores. It practically dances itself. Second of all, Sterling Hyltin and Robert Fairchild were a convincing pair of young lovers. Robert Fairchild in particular -- boyishly handsome, he reminded me a bit of Angel Corella. Sterling Hyltin is saddled with choreography that's little more than a lot of leaping and some awkward lifts, but she's more feminine and lyrical than many of the NYCB women. Her Juliet may lack some emotional depth, but it has a youthful energy and sympathy. I'm not sure she's ready to be principal dancer yet.
I remember watching Romeo and Juliet with Ferri a few years ago and at the end of the night the audience was stunned silent. Martins' R+J doesn't have that power. But still, I wouldn't say I wasted my time. It was worth seeing.
